- Peter Pan: Dan Perkins
- Captain Hook/Mr. Darling: Robb Dimmick
- Wendy: Elizabeth Cassarino
- Tiger Lily: Jill Perkins
- Smee: Todd Lamson
- Mrs. Darling: Bridget Lamothe
- John: Justin Gonsalves
- Michael: Tom Perkins
- Nana: Matt Collins
- Jane: Jessica Rivera
- Crocidile: Eric Graff
Pirates
- Misty Harbor: Holly Ackerson
- Brandy Port: Kimberly Lang
- Mad Dawg: Elton Bueno
- Rotten Rupert: Bob Clay
- Cecco: Matt Collins
- Sal Washbuckler: Brian Dembkoski
- Scurvy: Christopher Eschenbach
- Shiver Metimbers: Eric Graft
- Anchor: Ed Hadad
- Starkey: John Hatab
- Mog: William Hopkins
- Brown Beard Michael P. Jensen
- Noodles: Tim Keefe
- Blarg: Matt Leonard
- Mousey the Shrew: Ron Parent
- Spoons: Jay Moskowitz
- Short Gold Bob: Derrick Rose
- Vamp: Andrew B. SMith
- Rickets: Aaron L. Witham
- No Beard: Travis Milliken
Indians
- Rainbow Dancer: Andrea Aldrich
- Broken Knee: Noni Anderson
- Twin Bear: Dennise Bartelo
- Mountain Flame: Pamela Beland
- Flying Dove: Lauren Blake
- Moonfall: Sandra Bogalhas
- Big Blue Eyes: Cheryl Cole
- Dancing Bear: Jen Crane
- Aurora Dawn: Jennifer Desloges
- Blue Aruam: Maura Hanningan
- Pocohantas: Lindsay Hanson
- Morning Glow: Luaren Keefe
- Golden Taura: Echo Love
- Keemah: Robbin M. MacVittie
- Moon Doggy: Barbara McCahan
- Winged Harmony: Rebecca Rankin
- Night Blossom: Traci Tucker
- Mountain Stream: Joan Wiegers *
- Ginger of the Forest: Kim A Wothley
* Dance Captain
Lost Boys
- Ed: Zachary Baldwin
- Nibs: Marianna Berstrom
- Pips: Ryan Blake
- Slightly: Colleen Boyle
- Pockets: Nick Burtt
- Franky: Cathleen Clark
- Fumbles: Jamey Cooney
- Smudge: essie Daigneault
- Inky: Amanda Postman
- Ralphy: Jennifer Hanks
- Mortimer: Tom Hanks
- Izzy: Ryan Keefe
- Chips: Joanie Kietzman
- Spunky: Mac MacVittie
- Elmo: Jessica Maybew
- Sammy: Whitney McCormack
- Winks: Katie Mitchell
- Tummy: Kat Murphy
- Pepper: Elizabeth Naro
- Pippin: Mara O'Malley
- Mushey: Jessica Riveria
- Sneaker: Katie Young