- Does the paper meet the length requirement?
- Does each subsection contain the appropriate information?
- Is any information missing from a subsection?
- Is there any information that needs to be moved to a different section?
- Is the paper clear and easy to read?
- In each section, is the information presented clearly?
- On the paper, make a note in the margin at any points where you are confused or have to concentrate to understand.
- Has the paper been adequately proofread?
- As you read the paper, make penciled notes on it where you think improvement could be made in areas such as
- spelling
- punctuation
- capitalization
- style
- general presentation
- As you read the paper, make penciled notes on it where you think improvement could be made in areas such as
- What do you think would help the author improve the paper?
- How could this become an A paper? Try to list at least three suggestions.
